A discussion on english being the national language of the united states

Of course, few outside of linguists tend to make the distinction between American, Canadian, and true English in everyday conversation. The argument they are most adamant about concerns the violation of civil rights and liberties associated with the legislation.

This most famous of language legends began when a group of German-Americans from Augusta, Virginia, petitioned Congress, and in response to their petition a House committee recommended publishing three thousand sets of laws in German and distributing them to the states with copies of statutes printed in English as well.

With a purchasing power in excess of billion, the U.

Should English be the official language of the United States?

House of Representatives, th Congress. However, for the majority of these states this declaration is viewed as symbolic, comparable to selecting a state flower. The truth is, the US is very multilingual.

Performed with ease or clumsiness, awareness or not, guile or good faith, it is none the less something that must be enacted and portrayed, something that must be realized.

Individuals who oppose establishing an official language have alternative feelings of unequal treatment, discriminatory action, view multilingual as an asset, and believe such legislation is unnecessary.

Opponents also fear that this type of legislation will lead to ethnic and racial intolerance, and confirm to non-native English speakers that they are second class citizens in the eyes of the government of the United States ACLU. For other states such as California and Georgia, Official English statutes that are more restrictive, i.

This movement is primarily being headed by members of the Republican party, as well as organizations such as U. Novemeber to Available: Of all the foreign languages spoken in the country, Spanish is the language spoken most frequentlyaccording to the Census Bureau.

Publishers provide textbook materials in Spanish at the request of certain states, so many books are being translated. In order to successfully compete on the international market, it is important for individuals to acquire foreign language skills.

Similarly, their participation in the electoral process will most likely increase and therefore assure them a more notable presence in the democratic process U. This is a bad combination in public policy; a right that cannot be provided adequately that nevertheless adds billions of dollars in extra costs for US government and taxpayers.

Debate: English as US official language

Who is English First?. This would unreasonably burden government services, adding a huge layer of bureaucracy and costs. Thus, the Articles of Confederation along with other documents printed by the first Continental Congress were published jointly in German and English.

As was seen earlier, if a significant percentage of individuals believe this type of legislation should exist, and also believe that bilingual ballots should be used when necessary, as well as the implementation of bilingual education, a compromise needs to be reached. And, Switzerland is a country that has very strong unity and economic functionality.

The first is that by forging resistance to languages other than English, English Only legislation undermines the country's commitment to the development of bilingual education programs.

This bill may be left up to interpretation as Section 2 stipulates that "Congress and the States shall enforce this article by appropriate legislation.


Restricting federal and state employees from communicating with individuals, especially immigrants, in a language other than English violates the first amendment according to these opponents. While it only has 1, native speakers, Hawaiian is one of the official languages of Hawaii along with English.

The US Census reports that Knowledge of English also creates greater economic opportunities, as most non-English speakers remain in low-skilled, low-paying jobs. Real forms of discrimination aim at the inherent characteristics of an individual that they cannot change such as their skin color or national origin.

Urban Legend: German almost became the official language of the US

From this standpoint stems two additional concerns. The Debate Over English Only. By the turn of the century, Czech, Dutch, Italian, Norwegian and Polish bilingual education programs had also been implemented throughout the country National Education Association.

Survey participants were also questioned as to their feelings on bilingual education. Multilingualism in the United States is nothing new, either: This isn't about race. One prerequisite of being an American, as we have seen, is the ability to speak English.

Immediately following the appeal with AOE, Ms. In order to accurately debate this issue however, it is necessary to discuss the state of affairs that currently exist in this country.

His proposal was deemed "undemocratic and a threat to individual liberty. It is vital for law makers to take into account the goals and ideals of the very people they represent. Debate For Official English Policies Proponents of Official English laws argue various reasons as to why such legislation is necessary.The California senator S I Hayakawa introduced the first ‘English Language Amendment’ (ELA) inseeking to declare English the official language of the US, while overturning any state or federal statutes requiring the use of other languages.

The result is the proposed English Language Amendment (ELA), a Constitutional amendment making English the official language of the United States. Despite the latest rehearsal in Ann Landers' advice column of the myth that German had once come close to replacing English in the United States, Americans have never had a legally-established.

Though the United States has no official language at the federal level, bills are continually introduced in both houses of Congress calling for the. But don’t feel bad, the vast majority of people would answer that English is the official language of the United States of America.

English is the de facto language since, at this point, it is the most widely spoken language in the nation. Conservatives have urged President Trump to designate English as the official language of the United States, arguing it is the true American kitaharayukio-arioso.com who wants to become an American or participate in U.S.

society should speak the language—or get out. Half the countries of the world have an official language. The United States isn't one of them. The debate over whether we need an official tongue dates back at least to the s.

A discussion on english being the national language of the united states
Rated 5/5 based on 27 review